Here’s Why The Hyundai Genesis Coupe Is Today’s Fox Body Mustang

In 2009, a new affordable rear-wheel-drive performance car was making a buzz, and it didn’t come from the usual suspects. It wasn’t the then-new facelifted S197 Mustang GT, the reborn Camaro, or even the Nissan 370Z. Since the Scion FR-S and Subaru BRZ didn’t exist yet, it was the Hyundai Genesis Coupe that was the hot, small, affordable coupe of the moment. Fourteen years later, it’s in the same place the iconic Fox Body Mustang was when it was a well-used car — a sedan-based coupe that despite its shortcomings, is willing to indulge in shenanigans.

In the beginning, there was Genesis. Specifically, there was the Hyundai Genesis sedan, a surprisingly cromulent Mercedes-Benz E-Class competitor complete with a waterfall grille and a Lexicon sound system. It’s not the car you’d expect to spawn an affordable sports coupe, but that’s exactly what happened. On March 19, 2008, a fire engine red Genesis Coupe slid onto the stage at the New York International Auto Show, quickly followed by a silver one and pyrotechnics, signaling to the world that Hyundai was here to party.

The Hyundai Genesis Coupe was unlike anything Hyundai had ever made up to this point. Rear-wheel-drive, choice of a two-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine or a 3.8-liter naturally-aspirated V6, a proper manual or a six-speed automatic with paddle shifter, available Brembo brakes, and an available limited-slip differential. It was radical enough to upset the automotive paradigm. As 0-60 Magazine wrote: “The rear-wheel-drive, affordable sports car we all wanted is here. Funny thing is Hyundai built it.”

Keep in mind, this was the same company that had only discontinued the Tiburon one year prior to the unveiling of the Genesis Coupe, and that thing was a long-in-the-tooth front-wheel-drive liftback coupe with its roots firmly in the early 2000s. Sure, you could get it with a 2.7-liter V6, but it had nothing on the Genesis Coupe when it came to looks, let alone oversteer.

On the face of things, the Genesis Coupe had some stuff going for it. Track and R-Spec trims got adjustable camber bolts and a Torsen limited-slip differential, the available Brembo brakes were fantastic, the optional V6 engine was strong with 306 horsepower on tap, and planting your right foot would happily send this coupe’s tail out. So why did we all forget about the Hyundai Genesis Coupe? Well, first shots are never perfect, and the Genesis Coupe didn’t quite feel finished. While it’s cool that this car exists, Car And Driver tore into the two-liter R-Spec model, writing out a list of faults.

Although the car’s primary controls are well positioned and the steering offers decent feedback, hustling the car beyond a commuting pace reveals the notchy and imprecise nature of the gearbox. The ride is rather poor; the chassis feels willing and stiff overall, but the springs and the shocks never appear to know what each other is doing, making for noticeable body movement and harsh, crashing impacts over most bumps. Then there’s the underpowered 2.0T. We’ve experienced firsthand turbo tuners that sabotage a car’s drivability in the quest for more boost, but until Hyundai decides to offer the 2011 Sonata sedan’s optional 274-hp, direct-injected turbo-four in the Genesis coupe, an outside supplier is the only way to get the extra oomph the coupe’s chassis can handle (stepping up to the V-6 notwithstanding).

The current engine’s 223 lb-ft of torque at 2000 rpm make for good low-speed drivability and the car is very controllable if you manage to get it a little sideways, but with only 210 hp on tap, the throttle has a limited say in the car’s behavior. What’s more, the 2.0-liter engine—the foundation of which Hyundai developed in an alliance with Mitsubishi and Chrysler—sounds coarse and droning at all speeds, delivering precisely zero invigorating noises of the type that make driving a good performance car special and fun.

Ouch. It didn’t help that in Car And Driver testing, the two-liter turbocharged Genesis Coupe in lightweight R-Spec trim ran from zero-to-60 mph in 6.8 seconds, which meant it could be handily beaten off the mark by a Honda Civic Si, let alone a Chevrolet Cobalt SS. In many ways, the 2010 Genesis Coupe felt like a cut-rate Infiniti G35. It tried to emulate a more expensive, more sorted coupe and didn’t quite make the grade.

Mind you, Hyundai is an automaker that moves fairly quickly. For the 2013 model year, the Genesis Coupe was facelifted, and it gained a raft of upgrades. The four-cylinder engine saw its output rise from 210 horsepower to 274 horsepower, and the V6 gained 42 horsepower for a total output of 348 horsepower. The automatic became an eight-speed unit, suspension tuning got revised, the interior gained some gauges, and new styling made the car more aggressive or a little bit frumpy, depending on how you feel about single-frame grilles and fake vents. While the improvements were significant and appreciable, they weren’t quite enough now that the Scion FR-S and Subaru BRZ existed. Instead of a sporty coupe based on a sedan, thrill-seekers could have a sports coupe that drove like an actual sports car for cheap. However, that was 14 years ago, and this is now. Because everyone forgot about the Hyundai Genesis Coupe, they’re now going for even cheaper than the Scion.

For instance, here’s a 2010 Genesis Coupe 3.8 GT up for sale on Craigslist in New Jersey for $5,900. Sure, it may have a roof spoiler, 171,402 miles on the clock, and a Crown Royal bag as a shift boot, but it’s $5,900 for a post-recession rear-wheel-drive six-speed manual coupe. If it’s been through as many rear tires as that shift boot seems to indicate, it’ll survive whatever you throw at it.

Maybe you want a facelifted model. No problem, here’s a 2013 V6 six-speed manual car up for sale on Craigslist in Georgia for $6,000. Sure, it may have a conspicuous amount of plasti-dip visible, but again, here’s a reasonably quick rear-wheel-drive, six-speed manual coupe that’s more spacious than a Scion FR-S and still reasonably priced, given the current market.

The Hyundai Genesis Coupe isn’t the segment’s best all-around performance car, but the forgotten facelifted model is much better than the original, and overall, given its age and how cheap examples often go for, it’s a great fuck-around car, just like the Fox Body Mustang was when it was nigh-on 15 years old. It will indulge in all of the well-judged degeneracy you could want while still having enough amenities to feel somewhat modern. Every backroad peel-out and rainy empty parking lot skid you desire, it’ll oblige, and it’s easier to find a cheap Genesis Coupe than a similarly-priced not-clapped-out manual Infiniti G35. Sure, the two-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engines did have a reputation for going boom, but if you can find a V6 or don’t mind the idea that the next owner will be a scrapyard, a Genesis Coupe isn’t a bad way to explore rear-wheel-drive.

Plus, the Genesis Coupe is tuneable, with fairly strong aftermarket support. If you don’t like the suspension tuning, buy coilovers you’re fond of. A litany of power mods from flash tunes to turbos can wake up output, and a short shifter can fix the somewhat rubbery linkage. With a few bolt-ons, a Hyundai Genesis Coupe can be a cheap and somewhat sketchy source of fun, just like late Fox Body Mustangs were in the mid-2000s. If you’re just looking to screw around, this used Hyundai is a pretty good option.

(Photo credits: Hyundai, Craigslist Sellers)

Support our mission of championing car culture by becoming an Official Autopian Member.

• The Acura RL SH-AWD Is An All-Weather Flagship Luxury Sedan That Won’t Leave You High And Dry

• The 2nd-Gen Mercedes-Benz CLK Is A Pillarless V8 Coupe You Can Genuinely Afford

• The Stylish, Ahead Of Its Time, Original Toyota Venza Now Offers Near-Lexus Refinement For Used Honda CR-V Money

• The Lincoln MKZ 3.0T AWD Might Just Be The Cheapest Way To Get A Sedan With 400 Horsepower And Apple CarPlay

• Here’s Why The 2006-10 Infiniti M45 Is The Greatest Sports Sedan You Forgot About

Got a hot tip? Send it to us here. Or check out the stories on our homepage.