Poetry In Motion: 1989 Nissan Stanza Sedan vs 1986 Nissan Stanza Wagon

Sbsd 1 19 2024
ADVERTISEMENT

Happy Friday, Autopians! Another week in the books, and what a week it has been. I’ve been stuck at home all week due to the weather, but it looks like we’re turning a corner now. For the last day of this weird week, I want to show you two examples of the same car, courtesy of the folks in the Underappreciated Survivors Facebook group.

Yesterday, we went down to Cow Town and looked at a horned Lincoln and a spotted Neon. I assumed the hot-rod Lincoln would run away with it, but lo and behold, the little Neon won. I realize that many of those votes were qualified with “despite the automatic,” but still, it’s nice to see a car I really like win one.

And yes, that’s basically the same three-speed automatic Chrysler had been using ever since the K-car days, and it’s similar in design to the rear-wheel-drive Torqueflite automatics that date all the way back to the 1950s. Who cares? Maybe I just don’t have very refined taste (actually, I know I don’t), but I’m perfectly happy with a simpler version of something, if I can rely on it. I don’t need fancy stuff like a fourth gear.

Screenshot From 2024 01 18 15 42 09

Now then: It’s hard to remember, when you see a beat-up Altima weaving in and out of traffic, or when the rental company tells you all they have left are three Versas, but Nissan used to be a respectable automaker. Perpetually lagging behind other Japanese makes in sales, Nissan made and sold some really good cars thirty or forty years ago. But they weren’t memorable cars, except for the fast ones. Today we’re going to sing the praises of the neglected middle child of Nissan’s lineup, the Stanza, and remember that at least one version had a really great trick up its sleeve.

1989 Nissan Stanza GXE – $3,000

420144795 382550300990350 4067042165830954128 N

Engine/drivetrain: 2.0 liter overhead cam inline 4, four-speed automatic, FWD

Location: Rochelle Park, NJ

Odometer reading: 32,000 miles

Operational status: Ad doesn’t really say, actually, but I assume it runs and drives

1982 was a big year for Nissan in the US. The brand name change from Datsun to Nissan began, and along with it, the model numbers were replaced with actual names. Two of those, the Sentra and the Stanza, were all-new cars. The front-wheel-drive Stanza replaced the rear-wheel-drive Datsun 510 which replaced the 710, though all three were called the Nissan Violet and/or Auster in Japan. I can’t help but wonder if its sales might have been better if Nissan had not kept changing the names of things.

420479192 382550310990349 2649213012960883987 N

The Stanza is powered by Nissan’s fuel-injected CA20E four-cylinder, putting out 105 horsepower. Its performance was on par with similar cars of the day, which is to say slow. This one has an overdrive automatic, but even a manual Stanza is pretty pokey. This car sounds like the quintessential “little old lady who only drove to church” car; it has had only one owner, and covered only 32,000 miles. It’s practically a time capsule.

420201053 382550374323676 8628375011957501818 N

This car makes me miss the days when car interiors came in more colors than just black or gray. Common practice was to make the inside match the outside, like this one. It does make junkyard-diving for parts a bit more difficult, of course; you can always find the missing or broken piece of trim you need, but never in the right color. This one doesn’t appear to need anything, but there is an odd wear pattern on the driver’s seat, like the owner had something in their pocket all the time or something. At least it’s not worn through.

419257832 382552284323485 1479401519046514362 N

Outside, it’s straight and shiny, as you’d expect from a garaged car with so few miles. It may not be the most exciting thing on four wheels, but it’s also a practically new thirty-five-year-old car, cheap.

1986 Nissan Stanza Wagon – $2,250

418303950 907375457564108 4588139421695920887 N

Engine/drivetrain: 2.0 liter overhead cam inline 4, five-speed manual, FWD

Location: El Cajon, CA

Odometer reading: 104,000 miles

Operational status: Only says “great on gas,” so I guess it runs and drives?

The four-door sedan wasn’t the only Stanza model available, though. This is the Stanza Wagon, which was known as the Nissan Prairie in Japan. Though they called it a wagon, this is in some ways closer to a van; it has sliding doors on both sides (more than a decade before Chrysler’s minivans), but there’s more: There is no B-pillar. Open the front door and the sliding door, and you’re faced with a massive hole in the side. This makes it incredibly easy to get people – or stuff – in or out, but I imagine you couldn’t get away with it these days, with modern side-impact standards.

420224337 907374607564193 4141539340873890615 N

The doors latch at the top and bottom, so they can be opened independently; you don’t have to open the front door before the rear door, like on a Honda Element or a Saturn coupe. It’s a really neat bit of engineering. The basic platform on which this clever, upright body rides is not the same as the Stanza sedan; it’s related to the smaller Nissan Sunny (Sentra in the US). It does, however, have the same CA20E engine. This one is a five-speed manual, and also pretty low mileage. It has had a “bunch of maintenance” done to it, which I presume means it runs well, but once again, the ad is light on details.

420180010 907374664230854 3700152758867183314 N

This is a California car, and I almost didn’t need the ad to tell me that. It has no rust, but the paint is baked to a chalky, matte finish. The only shiny paint is inside the door sills and under the hood. But personally, I’d take faded and chalky over rusty any day. Inside, it’s at least as clean as the red one, and once again, matches the outside.

420188272 907374674230853 7733719829502350995 N

It also has some wonderful ’80s touches like the grid pattern on the instrument panel, and speakers mounted in the ceiling in the rear. According to the seller, it sounds pretty good, too. So once again I have to ask: What would you play in it? Me, I’m thinking Level 42, specifically the World Machine album. No reason; it just seems to fit.

So there you have them: two different cars, about the same age, with the same engine, but very different overall. You can’t go wrong either way, I think, so it comes down to personal preference. Shiny old-lady sedan, or cool but faded wagon?

(Image credits: Craigslist sellers)

About the Author

View All My Posts

105 thoughts on “Poetry In Motion: 1989 Nissan Stanza Sedan vs 1986 Nissan Stanza Wagon

  1. OK, full disclosure on why it’s the wagon for me: I’ve had this brownish-orange, EU-spec 1983 Datsun Praire in my saved ads for a loooong time, and I find myself daydreaming about it every now and then. Initially the owner was asking for a steep €4500, then after a few months it was lowered to €4000, and a few more months later it was changed to €4000 negotiable. It’s been like that ever since, which is probably about 1 year now. It’s in better shape than the one in the ad, and has super low mileage for how old it is (~80.000km), but I have a feeling that it’ll eventually sell for about half of what they’re asking for. Datsun/Nissan Prairies are extremely rare around here, but rarity in this case actually detracts from the price as it isn’t exactly a collector’s item, just a very unusual daily driver. Sourcing parts – apart from mechanical components – is probably hell. It shouldn’t be too hard to keep it on the road, but preserving its looks is a whole other story, and any minor fender bender could total the car.

    And yet, I keep convincing myself that it would be great as a replacement of my slowly dying 1998 VW Polo. I’d offer €2000 for it (willing to go to €2500) if my wife was on board. She is not.

  2. Wagon…it has always been the wagon for me. Loved the boxy looks, these sliding doors, high seating position and versatility. With rear seat and passenger seat removed (few screws) you could haul serious stuff (motorcycles). With all seating in place you could still stuff some lengthy tubes or planks all the way up to the front footwell (2.5 meters or more?), as they went under the rear and front seat. That’s a feature they should bring back!

    “which was known as the Nissan Prairie in Japan .. and Europe” (ftfy)

    ah, and music…Hüsker Du.

  3. We don’t need no stinking B pillars!
    Was just thinking about cars without B pillars; Facel Vega Excellence and Lancia Appia were on the list, Stanza wagon was not. Interestingly the Appia and the Stanza look like they have B pillars when the doors are closed as opposed to four door hardtops that have a vestigial B pillar when you open the doors.

    Wagon with a 5 speed? No contest!

  4. Seinfeld “Co Stanza” in “By Mennan” jingle. OR
    Seinfeld “Can’t Stand Ya” in George’s gym teacher voice?

    I think I’d take the wagon for the fun of an underpowered manual transmission car, but my god don’t get into a side impact wreck in that thing.

  5. Changing the name to Nissan and leaving the historically-charged “Datsun” behind was a huge Niss-Take, and it cost them market share. Datsun birthed The Fair Lady, 240Z, 510, King Cab etc. Why move sidewards from all that mojo and good will?

    I did vote the wagon–sumbuddy’s gotta be practical.

Leave a Reply