Driving My Nice New BMW i3S Around LA Makes Me Nervous So I’m Debating Keeping My Old One

David Over It Dents Scratches Ts
ADVERTISEMENT

I was riding up the 405 freeway yesterday when I heard a loud “BANG!” Someone had hit my brand new (to me), mint condition, Galvanic Gold, hyper-rare 2021 BMW i3S. I turned to see a motorcyclist splitting lanes ahead, wobbling from the impact. He continued riding; it was a hit and run. I drove to work, stepped out of the car, and surveyed the damage. “SON OF A BITCH!”

It was a scratch. Not a huge scratch, but a scratch. A white line on my mirror, and I was livid! Mostly because this biker had hit my car (possibly on purpose, since he was splitting lanes, and possibly punishing those who were maybe a bit off to the left) and just rode off with not a care in the world. That’s just unacceptable! It’s also possible it was an accident; either way, just stop if you hit someone else’s car — not cool.

Anyway, here’s the baby scratch on my mirror:

Screen Shot 2024 06 04 At 8.40.37 Am

The impact had been loud, so I was surprised the damage was so minor. Luckily, though, it wasn’t on the mirror housing’s gloss black section, which is painted, but instead on that coarse black plastic section, which appears to be injection molded and black all the way through.

This is actually a great design choice by BMW, because it means you can bang that mirror on a parking garage entry-ticket machine and, while you’ll sustain a scratch, you won’t be able to tell because that scratch’s valley will be the same color as the rest of that part of the mirror. I know this because look at how my mirror looks now:

Screen Shot 2024 06 04 At 8.48.32 Am

Looks pretty much all fixed! If you look closely, you can see some roughness from the motorcycle incident on the right half of this image:

Screen Shot 2024 06 04 At 9.11.59 Am

But for the most part, it’s repaired, and I’m happy with how the car looks overall. But it got me thinking: First, if a little scratch like this has me all concerned, I need to get XPEL PPF as soon as possible. And second, when is this “phase” going to go away? Like, surely not every scratch is going to bum me out forever, right?

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by David Tracy (@davidntracy)

My brother just bought a yellow Audi S3 recently, and he’s going through the same issue. He got a rock chip the other week, and it bummed him out. I used to have the same worry with my brother’s 1966 Ford Mustang and my 1993 Jeep Grand Cherokee “Holy Grail.” They were all just so nice that adding even a scratch to them could ruin your afternoon. Surely you, dear readers, can relate? When will I be released from this prison?

Anyway, my partner, Elise (that’s not her real name), suggests that I keep my 2014 i3 and use that as my errands car. I won’t care if someone hits its mirror or if a rock chips its hood — it’s older, it has higher mileage, and it’s not in mint condition. But does it make sense to have two i3s? Does it matter if it makes sense?

436731294 762774316025279 5534166180486123868 N

Maybe it doesn’t matter if it makes sense, and I should just own the cars I like, and when I get tired of one, I get rid of it. Maybe I’ll get tired of having two i3s, or maybe I’ll remain in this drunken-love state in which I see the i3 as an engineering masterpiece the likes of which we may never see again. Who knows? All I know is: I may be holding onto that gray i3 for my daily commuting — at least for a while.

203 thoughts on “Driving My Nice New BMW i3S Around LA Makes Me Nervous So I’m Debating Keeping My Old One

    1. Ouch. While I have definitely seen and met quite a few riders who merit your characterization over my 24 years of motorcycle riding, I’ve also met quite a lot who specifically don’t. Maybe it’s a regional thing?

  1. David, I generally like your writing, and MOST of your topics, especially about engineering, are interesting, but you do a lot of worrying and hand-wringing articles about, basically, bullsh*t. It’s a frigging scratch. Grow a pair, move on, focus outside yourself, and write more articles about suspensions or something.

    1. So he’s moved, got a gf, started a company (not sure if you heard about it), is writing about the anxiety a lot of us feel when driving new and/or rare vehicles, shared all of it, and your advice is a crass “grow a pair”? So he should write about a Macpherson strut instead because you’d rather read his writing about it than what’s on Wikipedia? To be fair, his writing is excellent but I’m not certain about the additive value to this website such an article would add.

      1. The Autopian is one of the best consumer-focused automotive websites that I read, with a good variety of topics an voices.

        But lately, the number of articles about the authors’ personal “trials and tribulations” about really minor stuff is getting a bit tiresome, IMHO, and detracts from the quality of the site.

        And BTW, if anybody feels actual “…anxiety…when driving new and/or rare vehicles…”, go to your local homeless shelter, hospital, or school for the developmentally disabled, where you’ll see people who have real problems to be anxious about.

  2. David, I generally like your writing, and MOST of your topics, especially about engineering, are interesting, but you do a lot of worrying and hand-wringing articles about, basically, bullsh*t. It’s a frigging scratch. Grow a pair, move on, focus outside yourself, and write more articles about suspensions or something.

    1. So he’s moved, got a gf, started a company (not sure if you heard about it), is writing about the anxiety a lot of us feel when driving new and/or rare vehicles, shared all of it, and your advice is a crass “grow a pair”? So he should write about a Macpherson strut instead because you’d rather read his writing about it than what’s on Wikipedia? To be fair, his writing is excellent but I’m not certain about the additive value to this website such an article would add.

      1. The Autopian is one of the best consumer-focused automotive websites that I read, with a good variety of topics an voices.

        But lately, the number of articles about the authors’ personal “trials and tribulations” about really minor stuff is getting a bit tiresome, IMHO, and detracts from the quality of the site.

        And BTW, if anybody feels actual “…anxiety…when driving new and/or rare vehicles…”, go to your local homeless shelter, hospital, or school for the developmentally disabled, where you’ll see people who have real problems to be anxious about.

  3. A car nut and wrench owning a pair of I3s? David is descending into madness. Hopefully should make for some good articles.

  4. A car nut and wrench owning a pair of I3s? David is descending into madness. Hopefully should make for some good articles.

  5. I’m going to buy two Corollas.

    That way I can park and preserve a Corolla while I put miles on the other Corolla. Than when I wear out the driving Corolla, I’ll still have a like-new worthless old Corolla!

  6. I’m going to buy two Corollas.

    That way I can park and preserve a Corolla while I put miles on the other Corolla. Than when I wear out the driving Corolla, I’ll still have a like-new worthless old Corolla!

  7. Understood completely, I absolutely Hulk out when I see a scratch or ding on a new ride, even if it’s an older car. The first scratch doesn’t lessen the pain of the second, third etc to me. Get the film on it ASAP. I use a similar film on my car and have had a couple instances of a scratch that just wipes off because it was only in the film- it’s definitely a “serenity now” moment when the film does its job and you can just rub out the scratch.

  8. Understood completely, I absolutely Hulk out when I see a scratch or ding on a new ride, even if it’s an older car. The first scratch doesn’t lessen the pain of the second, third etc to me. Get the film on it ASAP. I use a similar film on my car and have had a couple instances of a scratch that just wipes off because it was only in the film- it’s definitely a “serenity now” moment when the film does its job and you can just rub out the scratch.

  9. Someone randomly keyed my dad’s definitely non-mint corolla for no reason. Right on the top half of the driver’s side door. And another time they broke the rear passenger window. It doesn’t matter if it’s mint or not, people are stupid jerks. If I were you I would put on that XPEL stuff and just use it. It wouldn’t matter what car you were driving, the guy probably would have hit your mirror in any of them, it just happened to be your “mint” i3.

  10. Someone randomly keyed my dad’s definitely non-mint corolla for no reason. Right on the top half of the driver’s side door. And another time they broke the rear passenger window. It doesn’t matter if it’s mint or not, people are stupid jerks. If I were you I would put on that XPEL stuff and just use it. It wouldn’t matter what car you were driving, the guy probably would have hit your mirror in any of them, it just happened to be your “mint” i3.

  11. You terribly misunderstand the purpose of a ‘city car.’

    This thing was born to suffer a lifetime of bumps and scrapes. If you don’t have a new pair of marks on the bumper from someone else’s license plate screws then you’re doing it wrong.

  12. You terribly misunderstand the purpose of a ‘city car.’

    This thing was born to suffer a lifetime of bumps and scrapes. If you don’t have a new pair of marks on the bumper from someone else’s license plate screws then you’re doing it wrong.

  13. 1. Drive it and sell the first one. You’re in LA, not BFE with 2 cars driving through in a week.
    2. “Elise” is now “my partner.” That’s wild. And nobody so far had picked up on that. Jerks, the lot of them.

  14. 1. Drive it and sell the first one. You’re in LA, not BFE with 2 cars driving through in a week.
    2. “Elise” is now “my partner.” That’s wild. And nobody so far had picked up on that. Jerks, the lot of them.

  15. You’ve made your sacrifice to the gods of imperfection. Be at peace, and pray they don’t look unkindly on your repair.

    Next time, leave them an offering.

  16. You’ve made your sacrifice to the gods of imperfection. Be at peace, and pray they don’t look unkindly on your repair.

    Next time, leave them an offering.

    1. I genuinely do not understand the appeal of powered seats. They add cost and weight and move at a snails pace when you actually make any adjustment.
      Alternatively manual adjustments on seats are lighter, less costly and move quite quickly making adjustments.
      I can see the benefit of power seat adjustments though only if I were a paraphalegic or otherwise bodily impaired/abled enough that seat adjustments would be too difficult but I wasn’t physically impaired / able enough that I could still drive

    1. I genuinely do not understand the appeal of powered seats. They add cost and weight and move at a snails pace when you actually make any adjustment.
      Alternatively manual adjustments on seats are lighter, less costly and move quite quickly making adjustments.
      I can see the benefit of power seat adjustments though only if I were a paraphalegic or otherwise bodily impaired/abled enough that seat adjustments would be too difficult but I wasn’t physically impaired / able enough that I could still drive

Leave a Reply