Fell In Love With A Car: 2001 BMW 325i vs 2001 Mercedes CL500

Sbsd 6 18 2024
ADVERTISEMENT

Good morning! Today’s year of choice is 2001, and I’ve got two enticing German cars for your consideration. And if it wasn’t obvious from the title, today’s musical digression is the wonderfully noisy 2001 album White Blood Cells by The White Stripes.

Yesterday, we looked at two cars from 1983, set to the tunes of The Police’s album Synchronicity. Some of you took one look at the Sentra and thought “O My God,” while others thought that chasing down the Thunderbird’s fuel delivery problem would turn you into the King of Pain. In the end, however, it was the T-Bird that had you wrapped around its finger.

I have to say that, in this case, I’m Walking In Your Footsteps. The Sentra is an interesting curiosity, but there’s nothing compelling enough about it to make me want to own it. The T-Bird is at least a good blank slate for some fun, but don’t go too crazy, or every move you make, the cops will be watching you.

Screenshot From 2024 06 17 17 21 55

Let’s jump forward in time to 2001, and an album I love for a very specific reason. I am, as my friends know, a terrible guitar player. I’ve been playing since high school, but have never gotten serious enough to get any good, so I just bang out some chords when I feel like it and call it a day. I have discovered that, with my trusty MXR distortion pedal, I can kinda-sorta sound like I know what I’m doing when I play along with the right record.

So when I first heard the loud, distorted guitar intro to “Dead Leaves And The Dirty Ground,” I was hooked. I was already a White Stripes fan, but White Blood Cells was the album that really got me. (And then, of course, Elephant lost me again.) I love the energy of it. It sounds both way out on the ragged edge and completely in control at the same time. It’s deceptively simple, but I often catch some little nuance I didn’t hear before when listening to it. And if you agree, then I can tell that we are gonna be friends. Let’s look at some finicky, overpriced German cars together.

2001 BMW 325i Touring – $6,950

00m0m Hpa8zbnsal5 0hq0c2 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 2.5-liter dual overhead cam inline 6, five-speed automatic, RWD

Location: Santa Cruz, CA

Odometer reading: 193,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

BMW enthusiasts as a group are a funny bunch. They’ll extol the virtues of their cars at any opportunity, singing the praises of the smooth engines and the finely balanced handling, claiming that nothing else is as good to drive. Ask them about reliability, and they bristle and equivocate: Yes, it’s reliable – if you do the maintenance you’re supposed to do. Ask for specifics on what this “maintenance” entails, and you’ll get a long list of items replaced at what sounds like shockingly low mileage, even to someone used to GM and Chrysler cars. Mention that this sounds like a lot, and the response is a haughty “Maybe this car isn’t for you.”

00i0i Jeiijyi2axg 0hq0d4 1200x900

Well, in my case at least, they’re right: I have dealt with a BMW 325i of this generation before and was never so happy to see the taillights of any car disappearing after a sale. “Death by a thousand cuts” is the best way I can describe BMW upkeep. We only had it for three months, and I don’t think there was a weekend in that time I didn’t spend fixing something. Still, they are awfully nice cars to drive, and when I see a really clean one like this, in a great color, and a wagon, even, I start to think: Could it really be that bad?

00h0h E2ghzrgpx9d 0hq0bn 1200x900

This E46 wagon is claimed to be a one-owner car, and “very well maintained,” but it’s for sale at a dealer, so I’ll believe it when I see all the maintenance records. And at 193,000 miles, there should be a thick stack of them. It does look really clean, so if it checks out mechanically, it could be a safe bet.

00t0t 2uctdlcf6d5 0hq0d4 1200x900

And it’s a wagon, which is something you don’t see very often from BMW here in the US. That’s a shame, because wagons are incredibly useful vehicles, and BMW makes handsome ones.

2001 Mercedes-Benz CL 500 – $5,300

00a0a 73gm4ylin5j 0ci0t2 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 5.0 liter overhead cam V8, five-speed automatic, RWD

Location: Santa Clarita, CA

Odometer reading: 88,000 miles

Operational status: Runs and drives well

Now we turn our attention from a relatively simple and straightforward BMW to a nightmarishly complicated Mercedes. The CL-Class was the flagship two-door of the Mercedes-Benz lineup for a couple of decades, and during that time, the folks from Stuttgart threw every technological trick they had at this sleek coupe. This is the “entry-level” CL 500 model, and even it features Mercedes’s notorious ABC active suspension system and more tiny electric motors than a slot-car tournament.

00j0j Avb3crznimz 0ci0t2 1200x900

It sure does make for a nice car, though. The CL takes the concept of “personal luxury coupe” and turns it up to 11, with enough gadgets to impress even the most jaded country club patrons in 2001. And sure, this one isn’t an AMG or a V12 version, but it’s still a slick-looking pillarless hardtop coupe with a powerful and reliable V8 and Mercedes’s excellent 5G-Tronic automatic.

00d0d Bzpvwnmriqk 0ci0t2 1200x900

This CL 500 is also a one-owner car and has a scant 88,000 miles on its odometer. The seller doesn’t offer a lot of information about its history beyond that, though they do say it has new tires. But since the seller is also the one owner, you should be able to ask the right questions, and hopefully receive that coveted stack of receipts in return.

00h0h Ghoclzrdsoj 0ci0t2 1200x900

Of course, although it’s in great shape now, future troubles and their associated repair bills could strip the bloom from the rose in short order. This is a shockingly complicated twenty-three-year-old German luxury car, after all – not a vehicle for the faint of heart.

Though it isn’t explicitly stated in either ad, I’m sure both of these cars have pretty good stereos in them. Back in 2001, I think you would have been hard-pressed to find anyone driving around in either one blasting “The Union Forever” (“What would I like to have been? Everything you hate”), but time and depreciation have leveled the playing field a bit, so either of these pricey Germans could be your personal Rosebud for a lot less than they cost new. You can choose between a private-school-ready wagon and a senior executive’s chariot. Which will it be?

(Image credits: Craigslist sellers)

About the Author

View All My Posts

77 thoughts on “Fell In Love With A Car: 2001 BMW 325i vs 2001 Mercedes CL500

  1. I lived with a 2002 325is for 7 years. Not the estate version. I guess it wasn’t horrible mostly because I did all the work on it myself. One side of the fuel sender pair stopped working, leak at the sensor on the lower radiator, intake bellows cracked, recycler pump mounts cracked. This was over the course of 7 years. All were easy to replace except the recycler mounts. But before I could repair that I was t-boned in a construction zone by a driver who was ignoring the directions. I had 178,000 miles on it and it was still running strong. So, my vote goes to the BMW. It’s also in the same color as mine so nostalgia may be clouding my judgement.

    1. This is key for both of these cars- being able to do the work yourself. If you can’t, these aren’t the cars for you. Too many people don’t understand that.

  2. I lived with a 2002 325is for 7 years. Not the estate version. I guess it wasn’t horrible mostly because I did all the work on it myself. One side of the fuel sender pair stopped working, leak at the sensor on the lower radiator, intake bellows cracked, recycler pump mounts cracked. This was over the course of 7 years. All were easy to replace except the recycler mounts. But before I could repair that I was t-boned in a construction zone by a driver who was ignoring the directions. I had 178,000 miles on it and it was still running strong. So, my vote goes to the BMW. It’s also in the same color as mine so nostalgia may be clouding my judgement.

    1. This is key for both of these cars- being able to do the work yourself. If you can’t, these aren’t the cars for you. Too many people don’t understand that.

  3. CL. If I gotta pay the automatic tax, I’m paying it with a V8. Though when I looked at that rear end I thought, “What am I doing? I could just get a Lexus.”

  4. CL. If I gotta pay the automatic tax, I’m paying it with a V8. Though when I looked at that rear end I thought, “What am I doing? I could just get a Lexus.”

  5. The answer is always “the wagon.” I would absolutely prefer wagons over SUVs in every case except one…my old knees hate the squat thrusts to get into and out of cars. However, wagons are the superior mode of transportation (except for trains). Sorry, “estates” for my UK cousins…

  6. The answer is always “the wagon.” I would absolutely prefer wagons over SUVs in every case except one…my old knees hate the squat thrusts to get into and out of cars. However, wagons are the superior mode of transportation (except for trains). Sorry, “estates” for my UK cousins…

  7. I have dealt with a BMW 325i of this generation before and was never so happy to see the taillights of any car disappearing after a sale. “Death by a thousand cuts” is the best way I can describe BMW upkeep.”

    Yup… I’ve told people many times that there is no such thing as a cheap BMW.

    Anyway, my vote goes to the Mercedes… and it’s likely to be a far better bet than a nearly 200,000 mile BMW 3 series with a higher asking price.

    With that Mercedes, it would be a fun weekend car and I think it could even become a future classic… unlike a 200,000 mile BMW 3 series wagon.

    And that Mercedes is one of the pre-turbo ones… which is to say they’re not THAT complicated… by luxury Euro car standards. And I recall that Tavarish has some videos on fixing and maintaining these and owning one as a 2nd vehicle doesn’t seem to be that horrible as long as you’re willing/able to do a lot of the work yourself.

  8. I have dealt with a BMW 325i of this generation before and was never so happy to see the taillights of any car disappearing after a sale. “Death by a thousand cuts” is the best way I can describe BMW upkeep.”

    Yup… I’ve told people many times that there is no such thing as a cheap BMW.

    Anyway, my vote goes to the Mercedes… and it’s likely to be a far better bet than a nearly 200,000 mile BMW 3 series with a higher asking price.

    With that Mercedes, it would be a fun weekend car and I think it could even become a future classic… unlike a 200,000 mile BMW 3 series wagon.

    And that Mercedes is one of the pre-turbo ones… which is to say they’re not THAT complicated… by luxury Euro car standards. And I recall that Tavarish has some videos on fixing and maintaining these and owning one as a 2nd vehicle doesn’t seem to be that horrible as long as you’re willing/able to do a lot of the work yourself.

  9. The BMWs mileage is a plus in my book. Not likely to live this long without keeping it up. The merc feels like it’s right around the time you can stop getting away with ignoring stuff, and there’s way more, and scarier, stuff to ignore.

    B. M. W.

  10. The BMWs mileage is a plus in my book. Not likely to live this long without keeping it up. The merc feels like it’s right around the time you can stop getting away with ignoring stuff, and there’s way more, and scarier, stuff to ignore.

    B. M. W.

  11. Get the CL. Whenever a finicky little electric component gives up the ghost, ask yourself if you really need that particular feature. Let the small shit slide and you have a pretty nice cruiser for $5,300.

    Obviously the smarter purchase is something like an LS430 that won’t nickle and dime you to death. But if the choice is between these aging German cars, I’ll take the Mercedes.

  12. Get the CL. Whenever a finicky little electric component gives up the ghost, ask yourself if you really need that particular feature. Let the small shit slide and you have a pretty nice cruiser for $5,300.

    Obviously the smarter purchase is something like an LS430 that won’t nickle and dime you to death. But if the choice is between these aging German cars, I’ll take the Mercedes.

  13. I have a friend who already went through 4 years of torment with an ’01 325i Touring (in black), so at least I’d have someone constantly reminding me of all the things that need to be done, and someone who can identify every horrible sound and electrical issue. So, reluctantly, that would be my choice. And hey it’s a wagon (a great, right-sized one), and it’s in a color.

    The Merc scares the absolute shit out of me. And I’m not going to live in perpetual fear for the privilege of owning a beige car.

  14. I have a friend who already went through 4 years of torment with an ’01 325i Touring (in black), so at least I’d have someone constantly reminding me of all the things that need to be done, and someone who can identify every horrible sound and electrical issue. So, reluctantly, that would be my choice. And hey it’s a wagon (a great, right-sized one), and it’s in a color.

    The Merc scares the absolute shit out of me. And I’m not going to live in perpetual fear for the privilege of owning a beige car.

  15. Ooooof.

    The BMW seems overpriced despite the condition. High mileage and the mass-market model with an automatic, even though it’s a long-roof. It’s nice to see one in a color other than white, black, or silver/gray. Tan is the correct interior color, too, with that slate-like blue paint.

    If it were a Mercedes wagon against a BMW coupe it’d easily be the Mercedes.

    If it were a 5-series wagon versus the CL it’d be the BMW.

    I appreciate the B-pillar-less coupe look (does that make the typical C-pillar the B-pillar?) of the CL. It has a nice camouflage color, the ABC system I believe can be replaced with traditional mechanical parts as a conversion, and it’s a nice grand tourer.

    But I do really appreciate a wagon…

    Ooooof.

    Begrudgingly the Mercedes. It’s less expensive, much lower mileage, and could make for a fun weekend car for my winery runs and such.

  16. Ooooof.

    The BMW seems overpriced despite the condition. High mileage and the mass-market model with an automatic, even though it’s a long-roof. It’s nice to see one in a color other than white, black, or silver/gray. Tan is the correct interior color, too, with that slate-like blue paint.

    If it were a Mercedes wagon against a BMW coupe it’d easily be the Mercedes.

    If it were a 5-series wagon versus the CL it’d be the BMW.

    I appreciate the B-pillar-less coupe look (does that make the typical C-pillar the B-pillar?) of the CL. It has a nice camouflage color, the ABC system I believe can be replaced with traditional mechanical parts as a conversion, and it’s a nice grand tourer.

    But I do really appreciate a wagon…

    Ooooof.

    Begrudgingly the Mercedes. It’s less expensive, much lower mileage, and could make for a fun weekend car for my winery runs and such.

  17. BMW from a dealer with nearly 200k? No thanks. I love the Benz 5.0 V8 and that engine will go toe to toe with any other in terms of long term viability, if you can keep the electronics surrounding it happy.

Leave a Reply