Let’s End The Year With Some Dream Cars: 1977 Lotus Esprit vs 1974 Lancia Fulvia

Sbsd 12 29 2023 Ts2
ADVERTISEMENT

Good morning, Autopians! This is it, the final Shitbox Showdown of 2023. And I don’t know about you, but I could use a break from the junk. I feel like writing about something I actually want for a change, so today we’re going to look at two all-time dream cars of mine. Weird choices, I know, but hey – I’m kind of a weird guy.

Yesterday, we checked out two low-mileage American heroes, and I guess I’m not surprised that the wagon took an easy win. It’s a good deal on a really appealing car, which makes me wonder why it has been for sale for so long; that car has popped up in my searches for at least a couple of months now. I guess enthusiasts don’t want an Oldsmobile wagon, and folks just looking for a car aren’t willing to gamble on something that old.

I think the Concorde would actually be a nicer car to drive, but that rebuilt title does give me pause. I’d want to take a closer look. And that’s always the problem with these challenges, isn’t it? There’s only so much you can glean from a few photos and a bit of text. To really know a car, you have to drive it. Sights, sounds, feelings, smells – these will all tell you within short order whether or not a car is worth your time, no matter how good it looked in the ad.

Screenshot From 2023 12 28 17 17 05

All right. Yesterday’s Autopian Asks question got me thinking, not about cars I’ve driven, but cars I really want to drive and haven’t had a chance to yet. Some of them are just because of their shifter types – I want to drive any Ferrari with a gated shifter, and any Citroën 2CV-based car with that weird umbrella-handle thing – and others, like these two, are just cars I want to experience, but wouldn’t want to own. We’ll leave that headache to someone else. But I sure would love to talk my way into a test-drive of either one of these. Let’s check them out.

1977 Lotus Esprit S1 – $25,000

00x0x B6wwey9ipd1 0jw0ee 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 2.0 liter dual overhead cam inline 4, five-speed manual, RWD

Location: Elizabeth City, NC

Odometer reading: 47,000 miles

Operational status: “Runs strong, drives excellent”

It seems strange to me that after all these years surrounded by British car nerds, I have yet to drive any sort of Lotus. (Or any decent Jaguar, for that matter; just a couple of scruffy XJ6s here and there.) I got a ride in an Elan once when I was little, but that’s as close as I have come to Colin Chapman’s marvelous machines.

00n0n Km648uqpvcj 0jw0ee 1200x900

My first introduction to the Lotus Esprit was a yellow Corgi car when I was four or five years old. It was one of my favorites, and I carried it around everywhere. When my dad let me stay up to watch The Spy Who Loved Me a couple years later, and I saw a car just like my Corgi car turn into a submarine, I was in love. I knew nothing about Giorgietto Giugiaro’s “folded paper” school of design, or Colin Chapman’s insistence on performance through weight reduction; I just knew that the Lotus Esprit was one cool car.

00000 3ykfemvnfwd 0cc0gg 1200x900

This Series 1 Esprit is not a particularly fast car by modern standards; it could probably be outrun by a Toyota Yaris. It’s powered by Lotus’s own twin-cam “907” four cylinder, sitting just in front of a Citroën-supplied five-speed transaxle. This one underwent a complete mechanical overhaul several years ago, and it runs and drives beautifully.

00k0k 3qtrnyvl7ey 0jw0ee 1200x900

What isn’t quite as beautiful is the condition of the interior and exterior. It’s completely original, and the current owner has made a conscious choice to keep it that way. The red paint is chalky and worn through in places, the unassailably cool plaid upholstery is sun-faded, and the whole thing just looks a little tired. But I kind of like it; it has character, and I wouldn’t be afraid to drive it.

00808 Acd7hkhcbm9 0ij0ee 1200x900

This car still gives me the needy wants. I know the later turbocharged ones are faster, and I know it’s a fragile, high-maintenance nightmare, but I don’t care. The heart wants what it wants, and the Series 1 is the Lotus Esprit of my dreams.

Oh, and Jason would kill me if I didn’t point out that this car uses the taillights from another mid-engine sports car that I have wanted since I was a kid: the Fiat X1/9.

1974 Lancia Fulvia 1.3S – $27,750

00z0z 6metgwtbsya 0ci0t2 1200x900

Engine/drivetrain: 1.3 liter overhead cam narrow-angle V4, five-speed manual, FWD

Location: Miami, FL

Odometer reading: 31,000 kilometers

Operational status: Runs and drives beautifully, it sounds like

Poor Lancia. The fabled Italian marque barely exists today, selling only a sad little hatchback called the Ypsilon. But back in the day, Lancia was a force to be reckoned with. Italian cars and racing go hand-in-hand, and while Lancia didn’t only build road-legal cars so it could race them like Ferrari did, it wasn’t far off. Lancia’s biggest motorsport legacy was in rallying, with mid-engined monsters like the Stratos and 037, the ferocious and deadly Delta S4, and this lovely little coupe: the Fulvia.

00c0c I2uiectp1we 0ci0t2 1200x900

Unlike Lancia’s more famous rally machines, the Fulvia is front-engined and front-wheel-drive. It’s powered by a tiny, weird engine, a 1.3 liter V4 with only 12 degrees of separation between the cylinder banks. This narrow angle allows both banks of cylinders to share one cylinder head, a design later used by Volkswagen’s VR6 engine. To allow for a low hood, the Fulvia’s V4 is canted over to one side at a 45 degree angle. It sits in front of a five-speed gearbox, with the radiator off to one side, similar to ’80s Audi designs.

00j0j 3auivmulrl0 0ci0t2 1200x900

I always assumed, from the looks of this car, that it was a Pininfarina design, like so many of Lancia’s other cars were at the time. And it bears a resemblance to Peugeot coupes that were designed by Pininfarina. But this was an in-house Lancia design, and it’s a beauty. There isn’t a bad line on this thing. If you’ve never seen one in person, you’d be surprised at how small it really is. And if you’ve never heard one in person, you’re missing out. I don’t know how the Italians make engines sound so good, but they’re just music to a car guy’s ears.

01717 Xu5de7grsg 0ci0t2 1200x900

This Fulvia is all-original as well, according to the ad, and was imported to the US from Italy in 2021. It has only 31,000 kilometers on its odometer, and just had a “complete service,” whatever that entails. It sure looks like it’s in great shape, and I like the dark blue/tan color combo.

00u0u 5x8el1317dj 0ci0t2 1200x900

Some people, when they say they have a thing for Italian exotics, are referring to Ferraris or Lamborghinis or something even more boutique and exclusive. Not me. Give me slender roof pillars, sleek and simple lines, and a weird snarly four-cylinder engine.

Well, that’s it for this year! I hope you all have a happy and safe New Year’s Eve, and I’ll see you back here in 2024. In the meantime, which one of these two dream machines are you going to sweet-talk your way into driving?

(Image credits: Craigslist sellers)

About the Author

View All My Posts

66 thoughts on “Let’s End The Year With Some Dream Cars: 1977 Lotus Esprit vs 1974 Lancia Fulvia

  1. I would grudgingly take the cleaner of the two, it is far less crack pipe in a terrible Italian car sort of way.. But I would really rather have the bond car in white. in fact if money were not an option, I would send it straight away to https://www.watercar.com/ and at least partially make the thing water worthy even if it were not submersible.

  2. Faced with a somewhat difficult option, I defer to “which one would my wife actually want to ride in”. In this case, it’s the Lancia hands down. It’s a truly handsome machine as presented. I also have a soft spot for the Lotus, and the obvious awesomeness of the ’70s wedge/pop up headlight combo, but that Lancia is classy as hell.

  3. While the Lotus is definitely one of the cars of all time, I just can’t resist the sexy lines of the Lancia. The Lotus is a little tired, but I don’t really mind that and I actually think the chalky paint looks great. But design-wise it doesn’t hold a candle to the Lancia. Plus: weird V4! It’s a conversation magnet in every way and would be a blast to daily and take to car shows.

  4. I have LOVED the Esprit since seeing James Bond as a kid. The Submarine esprit from the Spy Who Loved me was cool, but I prefer the Turbo Esprit in For Your Eyes Only.

    If I had 25k to blow, I would be renting a Uhaul carrier right now.

  5. The Lancia is really nice, and I probably wouldn’t fit in the Lotus, but as you said, the heart wants what the heart wants… So I went Lotus. If the comparison was to a really clean Fiat or Bertone X1-9 at $10k or a scruffy 1960s Alfa Guilia for similar money I’d probably have gone Italian on this one.

    The biggest problem I have with the Lancia is that the Alfa mentioned above exists with similar looks, and had alfa’s larger engine plus RWD… As a fun project or weekend car off this type, RWD is pretty high on my list of desirable attributes

  6. Lancia please. Huge Esprit fan, and the condition doesn’t really bother me (I’d be too scared to screw up a nicer example anyway). But that price seems awfully high, and the Lancia is just… dreamy. I can’t think of many nicer looking FWD cars, that’s for sure.

  7. Where’s the “both” button? While the Lancia is cute, I’m a sucker for pretty much any Esprit. Glad I don’t have $20k lying around as NC isn’t very far from me.

  8. Inner child says Lotus, mature civilized adult says Lancia. Adult wins this round.

    If the Lotus was an injected non-turbo Series 3 the inner child would not be so easy to shush.

  9. Are you kidding me??? The Lotus Espirit is the archetype, the exemplar, the ne plus ultra, of the wedge! (Other than the TR7 of course.) Nobody had a Lancia Fulvia on their wall as a teenager! Plus, I I have to guess that Lancia parts are probably the only parts harder to find the Lotus parts. Actually the Lotus is made up out of an international parts bin, no? Unfortunately it’s a Fiat and British Leyland parts bin…

  10. November 7, 1986
    You’re watching Miami Vice.
    You think it’s just going to be a usual episode.
    Then things take a turn.

    A silver 1983 Lotus Turbo Esprit appears on screen.
    Who is driving this beautiful car?
    Mother. Fucking. Willie. Nelson.

    Remaking that car is the reason I chose the Esprit. I know it’s the wrong year and I know it’s going to cost so much more in dollars and labor to get it there than it will be worth. I don’t caaaaaaaaare.

  11. wedge car Wedge Car WeDgE cAr WEDGE CAR

    GIMME

    That’s not to say that Lancia isn’t an absolutely beautiful machine. But I’ll be danged if the best shape isn’t “high-speed doorstop”.

  12. The Lancia is a gem — It’s irresistible. It’s also the car that really proved that front-wheel drive could deliver sharp handling, if you just let the engineers loose on it. (I’m anything but a rear-wheel drive purist; I love good FWD designs just as much.)

  13. Lancia because a) I love weird cars, b) I really dig Lancias, and c) I jones for Italian cars. The latter is usually confined to Italian cars with twice or three times the Fulvia’s cylinder count, but I’m all about exceptions….

    The Lotus would be fun, but I’ve seen scruffy Esprits before and was not impressed. New ones weren’t screwed together all that well, so this should probably be treated as a kit car. I wouldn’t kick it out of my driveway, but would definitely make sure my tool kit was complete and I had parts suppliers on Speed Dial.

    Doesn’t matter. The Fulvia is just so sweet.

  14. During my overly extended late adolescence, I had two posters on my dorm room walls. One was of the Lotus Esprit S1 and the other was Farrah Fawcett, the twin fantasy lights of my boy-to-man era. Alas, I never got to ride in either one.

      1. If you think about it, they had a lot in common. One had The Hair, the other could be hair raising. One was a Lotus, the other looked good in the Lotus position. One turned into a sub you could pilot to the Bikini Atoll, the other looked great in no bikini at all …

        1. Well said. Every time I saw her on Charlie’s Angels, time would be spent on considering a move to LA and becoming a TV criminal.
          Or a bikini waxer in Beverly Hills.

  15. I’m going Lotus for no logical reason whatsoever. The Lancia is in way better shape and will probably be much less of a headache…but I can’t resist an Esprit. They’re just one of those cars that’s fascinated me since I was little. This seems rather pricey for the condition, though. I’d try to talk the seller down as close to 20 as they’d go.

    I may eventually wind up buying something like this as a curiosity/weekend toy, but I’m not sure that I’d want to make the leap of faith into a full blown British exotic. I’m not super mechanically inclined (yet, hoping to add a garage and start cutting my teeth next move) and I feel like if you can’t handle a lot of stuff yourself they’re absolute money pits.

  16. Lancia 10,000%. As noted, gorgeous lines and a unique piece here in the states. The Lotus needs a lot for the price asked, and while I like the Esprit, I’m not putting that money and effort into an S1.

Leave a Reply